Identity hijacking in sales


Read time: 1 min 30 sec

Let’s talk about one of the most manipulative sales tactics out there:
Identity hijacking

It’s when a business implies: “If you were a [desirable trait] kind of person, you’d buy this right now.”

You’ve seen some variation of this on sales pages. You've heard it on webinars.
Or you've been confronted with it on a sales call—which is less common cuz most people wouldn't dare do this in an actual conversation.

“Top leaders invest in themselves.”
"Are you gonna be the one who steps up or are you gonna be the one who stays stuck?"
“[Desirable identity types] don’t delay this decision."
"You've got two options: 1) Do the same shit and keep struggling or 2) Take the first step toward becoming a high-value woman / six-figure CEO...etc. by buying this today."
“The ones who enroll in my program understand that this is a small investment to pay for their future self."
"You can let your scarcity mindset run the show or you can embody your next level self. Your choice."

So now the prospect's decision isn’t:
“Is this the right purchase for me?”
It becomes: “Should I prove that I'm not a pathetic loser?"

That’s psychological manipulation dressed up as empowerment.
That's leveraging people's insecurities.

If you're reading this like "OMG I've done this before and I didn't realize what I was doing"—you're not a bad person.
You've just been duped by capitalism.

Capitalism has trained us to use people's identities as a bargaining chip in our sales cycle.
Capitalism has trained us to drown out a prospect's intuition.
Capitalism has trained us to shame people out of their 'no'.

But now that you know better, you can do better.

Your job is to help prospects make a well-informed purchase decision.

Here’s what that sounds like in practice:
“Here’s who this is for and why.”
“Here’s what this can realistically help you do.”
“Here’s what it won’t do.”
“Here’s what you need to be ready for before you join.”
“Your ‘no’ is welcome here.” (My personal favourite.)

It's not about convincing someone that they are (or aren’t) the “kind of person” who buys your offer.
It's about helping them decide from clarity, self-trust, and agency.

Let's honour the humans over our sales quotas.

Natalia

P.S. Totally unrelated but in case you need help shutting off your brain outside of business hours, too, the comment section came thru!

Harm Less, Sell Better.

The newsletter where personal brands learn to market themselves with integrity. I share humanity-first marketing perspectives, tips, and tools, sustainable marketing practices, and the highs and lows of my own marketing experiments.

Read more from Harm Less, Sell Better.

First, a personal life update: The family emergency situation seems to be settling down a bit but life is far from back to normal.Things are still...a lot.And somewhere in between all of it I'm slowly transitioning back to tending to my business. I know I'm not the only one who's in a season of running a business while facing hard things. I know because many of you shared that with me in response to my last newsletter. And for every one person who shares their story, there's gotta be at least...

Read time: 2 min 50 secSoo I'm behind on client work.I haven't mentioned my November promo in 9 days.And I didn't deliver content to my paid subscribers on Sunday like I usually do every week.In fact, I've barely done any biz-related things cuz I've been navigating a family emergency.At first, I found myself wishing that there was a rule book to guide solopreneurs who find themselves in challenging situations like mine.But then I realized that the rule book already exists. And I was...

Read time: 2 min 10 secConfession: I have a relatively low capacity for people-ing. I love people. And, depending on the situation, I can be pretty good at it. Buuut it takes a lot outta me. It’s why my family would find me hiding in the closet at parties when I was a kid.It’s why my phone is always on silent.It’s why it takes a good two hours after waking up before I’m willing to have a conversation.It’s why I experience JOMO (joy of missing out) a lot more frequently than FOMO.It’s why I’ve...